handcrafted ice cream
Made with love Lancaster, NY
Local Ingredients, Big Flavor
We work with local suppliers whenever possible. That means fresher dairy, better mix-ins, and flavors that feel close to home.
join us!
Private Events
Looking to add a sweet touch to your next private event? Big Papa’s Creamery brings the magic of handcrafted, artisan ice cream straight to you! Whether it’s a wedding, birthday, corporate gathering, or special celebration, our premium flavors and over-the-top experience will delight your guests.
Seasonal Flavors
Come on in and check out our seasonal flavors before they run out!
A celebratory classic – cake batter base with swirls of frosting, chunks of confetti cookie dough & sprinkles galore.
Toasted marshmallow base with pieces of chocolate and graham cracker crunch swirled in.
Blue raspberry, green apple, sour cherry, lemon swirled together to create this magical flavor.
ice cream catering
