Skip to content

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

Key Lime Pie (Dairy Free)

Light & tangy lime base with graham cracker crumbles.

See What
We're Scooping

newsletter

sign up for updates at Big Papa's Creamery

Email

Hours

Mon-Thurs: 2pm-9pm
Fri-Sat: 12pm-10pm
Sun: 12pm-9pm

Sun-Thurs | 12P-9P
Fri-Sat | 12P- 10P

Location

20 West Main Street
Suite 600
Lancaster, NY 14086

Links

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

Home
Location
- Menu
Upcoming Events
Private Events
About
- Jobs
Merch

copyright © 2026 | Big Papa’s Creamery | all rights reserved

Web Design by: JP Web Design & Media

follow us

Facebook Instagram